You are here
Home > Fantasy Baseball > 2017 Fantasy Baseball: Cheap Catchers

2017 Fantasy Baseball: Cheap Catchers

Catcher week continues on here at MLB Mayhem. If you’ve missed earlier posts in this series, check out the overview and ranks, a catcher I am targeting and one I am avoiding. With the catching pool being quite shallow and top-end talent rostered early, many fantasy owners decide to wait until the bottom of the player pool to jump in. With many of the solid catchers having deficiencies of their own, the players who inhabit the murky bottom of the ranking lists all have a glaring issue or two.

Today I want to try to find at least one redeeming quality the bottom-end catchers possess. Perhaps we’ll come away with a moderate target or two.

  • Yan Gomes (CLE): Yan Gomes has been a terrible hitter for two seasons now. Back in 2014 Gomes hit 21 home runs fully supported by underlying power metrics. Since that season however, Gomes has dealt with numerous injuries. The once well above average power is now merely league average. League average power can play with the right bat-to-ball skill, but Gomes also lacks in that area. A low 70’s contact percentage, coupled with a walk rate below five percent and you’ve got yourself a hacker. Despite showing power previously, Gomes has watched his Hard% sit considerably below the league average rate as well. A hitter who has average power, but a poor eye seems like the perfect candidate to have a semi-surprising below average Hard%. Gomes is that player. But still…15 Hr, 50/60 R/RBI & a sub .240 BA is playable in deeper mixed leagues.
  • Mike Zunino (SEA): From one free-swinger to another. While both Gomes and Zunino are complete hackers and perceived as power only catchers, Zunino appears to be the better bet to either improve in coming years or at least be the more consistent power hitter of the two. The interesting thing with Zunino was his ability to improve his walk rate from merely meh, to above average (11%). Zunino still has a ton of swing-and-miss in his game (16.4% SwStr%), but has decided to just swing less often it appears (3 year Swing%: 54.3%, 49.6% & 46.5% in 2016). As long as you’re able to accept that batting average will be sub-optimal, the power metrics behind Zunino’s profile look real as can be. Using Statcast data, we can see Zunino’s average distance per hit in play is well above the league average distance (249.80 feet vs 218.07 feet). Zunino is also hitting the ball with a launch angle that elevates the ball (17.94 degrees vs league average rate of 9.97 degrees). Zunino might not hit higher than .230, but he has 30 home run upside as well.
  • Francisco Cervelli (PIT): Cervelli feels like a watered down version of J.T. Realmuto who was covered earlier in this series. Last season injuries limited Cervelli to a half season of at-bats. During his time on the field Cervelli’s power metrics were all down substantially from their typical league average rates. While the hard hit ability was down for Cervelli, his batting eye improved considerably allowing for a decent batting average and middle of the road runs+RBI. If healthy in 2017, a combined 10 HR+SB, to go along with 90+/- runs+RBI and a .270 BA seems like the fair projection. You could do a lot worse this late in the catching pool.
  • Derek Norris (WAS): After taking a slight detour to discuss a semi well-rounded catcher, we’re back to the low batting average, high power potential backstop with Derek Norris. Norris had by far his worst season in 2016, hitting .186 (xBA of .212), which was justified with a drop in contact percentage (below 70% now) as well as a drop in consistently hitting the ball hard. This is strange as the Hard% found on FanGraphs does show a 34.4% rate, which would be a few percentage above the league average rate. In looking at Plate Discipline numbers, it appears Norris was swinging slightly less at pitches outside of the zone (O-Swing%), but was also making considerably less contact on those pitches outside of the zone that he swung at (52.6% vs league average rate of 63.9%). In fact Norris had a zone contact (Z-Contact%) of 85.6%, which was just below the 86.3% average in 2016. Using an ISO heat map from Brooks Baseball we can see that when the pitch is in the zone, Norris has a decent ability to drive the ball. When the pitch is outside of the zone and he swings the result is less than powerful. Norris is a player to watch early in the season and try to detect a possible change in approach which would unlock another level of power potential.










That will wrap up catcher week. The position isn’t overly exciting, but does offer some pockets to fish in. Personally, I’m quite interested in Jonathan Lucroy, Willson Contreras & Yasmani Grandal among the higher end catchers. If the dynamics of the draft do not allow for a selection of one of those three, then a fall-back plan of a Russell Martin, Welington Castillo or Brian McCann isn’t horrible for your catcher number one either. After the top-end options are gone, it’s going to be a later pick for me when selecting my catcher number two. Team needs will most likely play a role in this decision, but also what’s most likely available in the pool. As this post details, the likely available second catcher will be a poor batting average, high power potential stick. Make sure to plan accordingly and perhaps protect batting average some in your drafts knowing that a Yan Gomes, Mike Zunino or Derek Norris could weigh down the category for your squad.

Photo Credit: Keith Allison
Dave Morris Jr.
Creator of the 2017 Fantasy Baseball Draft Guide. Fantasy Baseball veteran. Multiple year champion in both single league and mixed league formats. Also a Seattle Mariner fan who blindly believes this year will be "the year".

38 thoughts on “2017 Fantasy Baseball: Cheap Catchers

  1. Work with an individual soft wash unpick this dust and additionally conceivable waterless are like a magnet on the boot styles before starting to clean.The substance regarding sheepskin support the aim o temperature adjustment, this perform could make this special cheap ugg boot offer th heated air with your feet, so be sure all you could body with thi wellbeing ailment and earn your feet sense fairly warm and dry. The moment they like to get back to their natural skin tone, they just have to remove the stain left by bronzers with water.If not, create your own play, complete with script, costumes and makeup!Action!9. The bankruptcy submitting need to only be carried out, for those who have tried most the possibilities for the debt support with not proved helpful for an individual at just about any price.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys

  2. I was more than happy to search out this web-site.I wanted to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely having fun with every little little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.

  3. 2、 提高监管效能。宁夏计量院的一氧化碳检测报警器检定装置、硫化氢气体检测仪检定装置和离子色谱仪检定装置3项新建最高计量标准顺利通过国家质检总局的考核,提升技术服务能力。我们公司一线工人年收入都在4.介绍了行业政策背景。法院依法判超市一次性赔偿王女士赔偿金1825元。 “北拓”新镇区;向南推动英东公路建设,以达到高压电能计量的革命性改变。受山东省科技厅委托,70 13.

  4. When you are looking for warm and really cozy coolest camping gear, look no further than Ukala boots. Ukala is the legendary Australian fashion brand that is known to product the most comfortable and exciting footwear designs. The coolest camping gear designed by the manufacturer are highly sought after in the International market. In this article, we will discuss a little more in detail about Ukala coolest camping gear and find out where to buy them at the best price.The collection by Ukala represents the elements of modern lifestyle. They are the perfect footwear for modern men and women looking for comfortable and stylish boots. The colorful tones used in making the product makes them all the more special. The footwear designs are also cool and urban. They use the premium quality material such as the natural suede and Australia Merino wool. They enable the feet to breathe easily and feel really comfortable.
    discount camping gear

  5. Justice Moore noted in his findings that: “The standard required for conviction of a criminal offence is proof beyond aDPP, Shalimar Ali-Hackreasonable doubt for every element of the offence – the acts as well as the mental ingredients.

  6. Concerning a legal organization in between you and the lenders is going to be productive for an individual. Power failure is a common cause of appliance failure. The residents of the countries that are beneficiaries are also taking the opportunity more seriously. You start with the oldest and proceed. The interior side is completed for the amount that assimilates a perspiration as well as moisture content trying to keep you dried up.

  7. Do you have a process for dealing with change orders? With a project as big as building your dream home, things are going to change during the development, whether it\s because you\ve changed your mind or worked with a designer who has deviated from the blueprint. Make sure that the contractor you choose has references of projects that have some of the same requirements as your job.”I just like the way he communicates and treats people,”hitting coach Jeff Manto said.There are many appliance spare parts centers, stores and dealers to buy the replacements from. For further details visit cjmackeypress.

Leave a Reply